Not the Jersey Shore you’d expect: Cape May NJ is the Perfect Getaway

Sharing is caring!

This post includes affiliate links. When you purchase through these links, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. For full details, please see our affiliate disclosure page.

Welcome to Cape May, NJ, a charming seaside haven at the southern tip of the Jersey Shore. This is NOT the Jersey Shores that you imagine, it is a historic town, nestled between the Atlantic Ocean and Delaware Bay.  It offers a perfect blend of Victorian elegance, pristine beaches, and outdoor adventures.

Cape May is not just a picturesque retreat; it’s an outdoor enthusiast’s paradise. Embark on hiking trails, marvel at butterfly migrations, and set sail on thrilling whale-watching tours. From captivating sunsets to family-friendly excursions, Cape May’s natural wonders beckon to be explored.

Cape May Boardwalk Credit DownshiftingPRO
Cape May Boardwalk Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

🏡 Where to Stay: Top Accommodations
🥾 Explore: Tours & Experiences
🚙 Hit the Road: Car Rental Deals
🛫 Get Away: Find Flight Deals
🎒 Shop: Travel Essentials

And what’s a getaway without delightful dining and fabulous shopping? Cape May caters to your foodie delights, from affordable seafood joints to fine dining establishments. Uncover the allure, natural beauty, and culinary delights that make Cape May an unforgettable coastal destination. Whether you’re seeking a romantic weekend or a delightful girl’s getaway, Cape May promises a perfect blend of cultural richness and fantastic experiences.

About Cape May, NJ

Situated at the southern tip of the Jersey Shore, Cape May is a charming seaside town known for its Victorian architecture, pristine beaches, and relaxed vibe. The city is designated the Cape May Historic District, a National Historic Landmark due to its concentration of Victorian buildings. In fact, it has the second-largest collection of Victorian houses, behind San Francisco.

Cape May Marina Credit DownshiftingPRO
Commercial fishing boats in Cape May Marina Photo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

Cape May began hosting vacationers from the Philadelphia area in the mid-18th century and was considered one of the finest resorts in America by the 19th century. High season runs from May to September but the fall was a wonderful time to visit.  The whole town was decked out in Halloween decorations and ghostly offerings.  Hotel availability is easier and more affordable.  This is a very vibrant (and busy) summer destination to consider during shoulder season. 

How to Get to Cape May, NJ

By Air

Unless you have a private jet or a chartered airplane, there is no commercial flights available to fly into Cape May. The nearest airport to Cape May is Atlantic City (ACY) Airport which is 40.6 miles away. Other nearby airports include Philadelphia (PHL) (67.8 miles), Baltimore (BWI) (95.8 miles) and Reagan Washington (DCA) (114.9 miles).

By Car

There really is no other way to get to Cape May than with a car.  The route from Philadelphia was very easy without traffic. If you are coming from other major cities, always check the fastest route and traffic to make your drive an enjoyable one.

From Philadelphia:

A mere 90-minute drive makes Cape May easily reachable for a quick escape from the city’s bustle. Take the scenic route down the Garden State Parkway or Route 9 for an enchanting coastal journey.

From New York City:

Between 2.5 – 3 hours, you can leave the urban landscape behind and immerse yourself in the tranquillity of Cape May. The drive from the city on I-95 to the Garden State Parkway is a perfect prelude to the coastal retreat that awaits.

From Atlantic City:

If you’re starting in Atlantic City, a scenic 60- to 90-minute drive south on the Atlantic City Expressway connecting to the Garden State Parkway South offers a picturesque route, setting the tone for your coastal getaway.

From Baltimore and Washington, DC:

Though a bit longer, the approximately 3-hour drive from Baltimore and 3 hours 45 minutes from Washington, DC, is a journey on I-95 is well worth the unique experience that Cape May promises. The drive allows you to escape the city and delve into the distinctive charm of this coastal gem.

By Ferry 

Cape May, NJ to Lewes, Delaware Ferry Service

From Lewes, Delaware

If you prefer a scenic and leisurely journey, consider reaching Cape May by ferry. The Cape May-Lewes Ferry provides a picturesque voyage across the Delaware Bay, connecting Cape May, New Jersey, and Lewes, Delaware. Here’s what you need to know about this maritime adventure:

Things to Do in Cape May, NJ

Washing Street Mall in Cape May, NJ
Cape May in the Fall Credit DownshiftingPRO

Shopping on Washington Street Mall:

Indulge in a leisurely stroll along Washington Street Mall, a charming three-block span of outdoor shopping. Explore quaint stores, discover unique finds, and savour the culinary delights of great restaurants scattered throughout this inviting area.

Cape May Stage Theatre on Lafayette Street
Cape May Stage Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

Take in a Play at Cape May Stage:

Immerse yourself in the arts by attending a play at Cape May Stage. This intimate theatre venue showcases a diverse range of performances, promising an evening filled with entertainment (we loved The Garbologists). Shenanigans will ensue as they open their holiday production of A Tuna Christmas.

Emlen Physick Estate, Cape May, NJ
Emlen Physick Estate Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

Visit the Victorian Mansion – Emlen Physick Estate:

Step back in time with a visit to the Emlen Physick Estate, a stunning Victorian mansion. Explore the meticulously preserved rooms, stroll through the manicured gardens, and gain insights into the opulent lifestyle of the Victorian era.

Take a Trolley Tour:

Victorian Mansions while on tour with Cape May Tolley Tours
Cape May Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

Hop on one of Cape May MAC’s cheery red trolleys and take a guided tour the easy and comfortable way. Knowledgeable guides will tell you everything you want to know about America’s first seaside resort, from our Victorian heritage to our seashore and maritime history and more, with plenty of fun facts sprinkled in. With a variety of tours, choose evening Spirits and Oddities,, Victorian Mansions by the Sea, Underground Railroad or History of Cape May Trolley Tours.

Visit Cape May County Park and Zoo:

Cape May County Park and Zoo is free but donations are always accepted.
Cape May County Park and Zoo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

For a family-friendly adventure, head to Cape May County Park and Zoo. Delight in the opportunity to see a diverse array of animals in a well-maintained and naturalistic setting, making it an enjoyable outing for visitors of all ages. I was very excited to finally see a capybara (the largest rodent in the world). They were pretty adorable!

Capybara at Cape May County Zoo Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO
Capybara at Cape May County Zoo Photo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

Outdoor Activities

Ecotourism is also prominent, featuring more than 400 recorded bird species, marine mammal watching trips, fishing trips and more. Discover the natural beauty of Cape May with a variety of outdoor pursuits:  Whether you’re seeking tranquillity on a hiking trail, marvelling at the delicate dance of butterflies, or embarking on a thrilling whale-watching tour, Cape May’s outdoor offerings are as diverse as they are captivating.

Hiking in Cape May Point State Park:

Lace up your hiking boots and explore the scenic trails of Cape May Point State Park. From meandering paths through lush forests to panoramic views atop the dunes, this park offers a perfect retreat for nature enthusiasts.

Fort Miles Battery 223:

WWII Bunker Cape May Point State Park Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO
Fort Miles Battery 223 – Bunker – Cape May Point State Park Photo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

Built in 1941 this WWII bunker was part of the Harour Defense Program to guard against German U-boat attacks. Decommissioned in 1964, it was turned over to the State of New Jersey to be used for recreational purposes. Curiosity seekers can only walk around the 6-foot-deep walls of this archaic concrete structure.

Track the Butterfly Migrations of Monarch Butterflies in the fall:

Witness the mesmerizing spectacle of monarch butterflies as they migrate through Cape May in the fall. The Cape May Monarch Monitoring Project provides a unique opportunity to observe and learn about these beautiful creatures.

Birding in the Spring and Fall:

Birders Cape May State Park Boardwalk Credit DownshiftingPRO
Birders Cape May State Park Boardwalk Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

Cape May is a renowned hotspot for birdwatching, particularly during the spring and fall migrations. The Cape May Bird Observatory, a hub for birding enthusiasts, offers guided tours and insights into the diverse avian species that pass through the region.

Ascend the Lighthouse:

Cape May, NJ
Cape May Lighthouse Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

Built in 1856, the Cape May Lighthouse is located in Cape May Point State Park, you can climb the 199 steps to the Watch Gallery. Standing 157.5 feet tall from the ground line to the ventilator ball on top, from the watch galler you will have a bird’s eye view of the Atlantic Ocean and Delaware Bay. Evening climbs are offered during full moons and new moons, weather permitting. All tours of the tower are self-guided.

Visit Cape May Point State Park:

Cape May Point State Park is free to the public, and an ideal location for birding, picnics, painting, photography, and nature walks. Explore ponds, coastal dunes, marshes, and forest habitats on one of the three hiking trails, which range from 0.5 to 2 miles in length. The shortest, the Red Trail, is wheelchair accessible. Download a detailed trail guide from the state’s website.

Dolphin & Whale Watching:

Whale Watch Cape May Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO 1
Whale Watch Cape May Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO

Embark on an unforgettable whale-watching excursion from Cape May. The waters off the coast are rich with marine life, and various tour operators offer the opportunity to witness majestic whales breaching the surface as they journey through the Atlantic.

Mining for Cape May Diamonds:

West Cape May sunset Paul and Margarita Ibbott Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO 1
Perfect Couples Getaway – Sunset Beach Photo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

Head to Sunset Beach and try your hand at mining for Cape May diamonds, small quartz crystals that are naturally polished by the ocean. This unique and family-friendly activity allows you to collect these sparkling treasures as souvenirs of your time in Cape May.

Where to Stay in Cape May, NJ

Elaine’s Cape May – Boutique, Hotel and Bar

Our hotel of choice was Elaine’s Boutique Hotel in downtown Cape May, NJ. Elaine’s is across the street from the Cape May Stage and a block from Washington Street Mall. Walking distance to the Cape May boardwalk and beautiful beach.  Family-owned for decades, this boutique hotel offers modern amenities, private parking, and unique ‘Signature Nest’ rooms for a memorable stay. With two bars, a restaurant, and on-site boutique shopping, Elaine’s is both a local and returned guest favourite.

Elaines Boutique Hotel Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO 1
Elaine’s Cape May Boutique Hotel – Photo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

With a variety of rooms from a huge contemporary suite with a fireplace to cozy Victorian-themed rooms. Some rooms have balconies overlooking the downstairs bar where you can watch the sunset in the distance.

Where to Eat in Cape May, NJ

Phinney’s Pub in Elaine’s

Elaines Restaurant Great Vibe Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO
Phinney’s Pub at Elaine’s Cape May – Great Vibe – Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO

Great variety and location Nestled in downtown Cape May, Phinney’s Pub offers a fantastic dining experience with great food and impeccable service. Recently renovated using the siding from a defunct fishing business, the decor is a throwback to the mainstay of Cape May – commercial fishing. The casual vibe is complemented by live music on the porch and bands playing on the weekends, making it a perfect entertainment spot for both locals and visitors.

Quincys Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO
Quincy’s Lobster Roll and New England Clam Chowder – Photo Credit: DownshiftingPRO

Quincy’s Original Lobster Rolls 

An authentic experience. A quaint storefront on Washington Street Mall, Quincy’s Cape May Mall is the go-to spot for those seeking a quick but genuine lobster, shrimp or crab roll. Their seafood chowder was also very good. Add a dash of seaside flavour to your culinary adventure.

The Lobster House

A bit touristy but a Cape May staple Immerse yourself in a traditional supper club atmosphere at The Lobster House. While the decor may exude a classic charm, the extensive surf and turf menu is anything but dated. A favourite among tourists, this restaurant promises a memorable dining experience.

Tisha’s

Tishas Fine Dining Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO

Fine Dining on Washington Street For an exceptional fine dining experience, head to Tisha’s on Washington Street. Known for its outstanding cuisine, this restaurant allows you to bring your own bottle of wine to accompany your meal. The seafood risotto is a standout dish, making Tisha’s a must-visit for connoisseurs seeking culinary excellence. Tisha’s came highly recommended and it did not disappoint – an outstanding meal!

FAQs about Cape May, NJ

Is it Worth Visiting Cape May?

Absolutely! Cape May’s unique blend of history, natural beauty, and cultural offerings makes it a must-visit destination for all types of travelers.

When is the Best Time of Year to Visit?

Each season has its charm, but many visitors find the late spring to early fall period ideal for pleasant weather and a vibrant atmosphere.

Where is the Best Place to See a Sunset in Cape May?

You have many options most people head to Sunset Beach just past the WWII Lookout Tower at the end of Sunset Blvd.  It is very close to Cape May Point State Park. 

Sunset Cape May Point Credit DownshiftingPRO
Sunset West Cape May Credit_ DownshiftingPRO

Otherwise, head to North Cape May to the corner of Beach Ave. and Lincoln Blvd. to a small parking lot (with an unmarked beach).  

Or head down further on Beach Ave. to David Douglass Sr. Memorial Park and watch the Cape May Lewes Ferry sail off into the sunset.  It was a priceless experience.

Where is the Best Place to See a Sunrise in Cape May?

Start your day with a serene sunrise at Cape May Point State Park, where the sun paints the sky over the lighthouse and Delaware Bay.

Day Trips from Cape May

Atlantic City Boardwalk The Tropicana Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO
Atlantic City Boardwalk The Tropicana – Photo Credit DownshiftingPRO

Embark on day trips from Cape May along the picturesque Atlantic coast of New Jersey. Spanning from Cape May to Sandy Hook, explore 127 miles of sandy beaches. Travel effortlessly between cities by car and stop by the bird sanctuary in Stone Harbor, stroll Wildwood’s lively boardwalk, ride the Ferris wheel in Ocean City, or experience the vibrant nightlife and casinos in Atlantic City.  Take the ferry from Cape May to Lewes, Delaware for the day and visit the antique stores in the ‘first town in the first state.’

Cape May Pinterest Pin Margarita Ibbott DownshiftingPRO 3
Cape May Pinterest Pin Margarita Ibbott DownshiftingPRO
Cape May Pinterest Pin Margarita Ibbott DownshiftingPRO 2

 🥾 Explore: Tours & Experiences
🏡 Where to Stay: Top Accommodations
🚙 Hit the Road: Car Rental Deals
🛫 Get Away: Find Flight Deals
🎒 Shop: Travel Essentials

3 thoughts on “Not the Jersey Shore you’d expect: Cape May NJ is the Perfect Getaway”

  1. Wow, who knew? Cape May looks amazing. It is now on our list for our east coast road trip next year. Thanks for the great information!

Comments are closed.